After the Open House: What the Feedback Tells You About Your Asking Price

It’s Monday morning. Eight groups came through your open house yesterday. One couple stayed for half an hour, three people mentioned the kitchen, and nobody made an offer. Should you lower the price?

I’d keep the price where it is until we answer one more question. When those buyers left your house, where did they go next?

Say two of them toured another rowhouse a few blocks away. It has an updated kitchen, it’s listed at the same price, and one buyer has already asked for a second showing there. Now we have a comparison worth pulling up. Maybe your house has parking and theirs doesn’t. Maybe theirs has a layout that would cost real money to recreate in yours. Those details can change my advice. The number eight, by itself, can’t.

If the open house was quiet, look at the whole week

We had a busy open house in Silver Spring and a slow one on Shepherd Street. If you’d been the seller at either property, the head count would have been the easiest thing for me to tell you. You’d still want to know whether anyone was coming back.

Ask your agent to put Sunday alongside the private showings. If two buyers came on Thursday, another came on Saturday, and one of them is bringing a partner back on Tuesday, you have a good reason to see what happens Tuesday. If the open house was quiet and the private showing calendar is empty, I’d start looking at what buyers see before they ever get to the door.

Pull up your listing on a phone, the way a buyer would. Can you tell from the first few photos what makes the home worth a visit? If it’s a DC condo with a second level and reserved parking, how far do you have to scroll to discover either? Then check how easy it was to arrange a private tour. If buyers struggled to get in, fixing access gives you a fairer read on the price.

If buyers came through, ask for their exact words

“The kitchen got some feedback” leaves a seller with a lot to guess about. Ask your agent what people actually said.

“I don’t like the cabinet color” tells you one person’s preference. “We couldn’t see where a table would fit” gives you a question you can answer. Measure the space. If a table fits, show how it works in a photo or on a floor plan. If it doesn’t, buyers who need an eat-in kitchen will value the house differently. Repainting the cabinets won’t change that.

The same goes for compliments. Someone can love your garden and still need an upstairs bedroom you don’t have. Ask what happened after the compliment. Did the buyer request the floor plan, bring someone back, or ask their agent to follow up? Those actions give you a better sense of what to do next. If a buyer leaves without giving a reason, leave that answer open.

When someone says “it’s overpriced,” look at the house they chose

Suppose you’re selling a Petworth rowhouse. Two buyers say yours feels expensive compared with the one around the corner. I’d open both listings with you. Would someone who wanted your house seriously consider that one? Look at condition, usable space, outdoor space and parking. Then ask which differences mattered to the people who toured both.

An active listing shows what else a buyer can choose today. A recent closed sale shows what a buyer actually paid. A home that went under contract over the weekend gives us another clue, although we may have to wait until closing to learn the price and terms.

I’d be more inclined to recommend a price change if buyers can easily tour your home, they understand what it offers, and several independently favor comparable homes that offer more at the same price. If I recommend a new number, I should be able to show you the properties behind it and explain why a buyer looking at those homes would give yours another look.

What to ask your agent on Monday

You can cover the important ground in one conversation:

  1. Who took a next step? Ask about return visits, requests for documents and private showings already on the calendar.
  2. Which comment came up more than once? Get the wording while it’s fresh. Find out whether buyers raised it on their own or in response to the same question.
  3. Which other home keeps coming up? Have your agent show it to you alongside a recent comparable sale.
  4. What should we do this week, and when will we revisit it? Agree on one action and a time to compare notes.

That last question keeps you from spending another week wondering. “We’ll call the agents who toured both houses and talk after Tuesday’s second showing” gives you a reason to hold the price and a point at which to reconsider. If the comparisons already support a change, you can have that conversation on Monday.

A few questions sellers ask after an open house

How many visitors make an open house successful?

I wouldn’t give a seller a target head count. One visitor who comes back with their partner gives us someone to follow up with. A full sign-in sheet with no return visits calls for a closer look at what buyers chose next.

Should I fix something buyers keep mentioning?

First find out whether it’s a misunderstanding, an inexpensive fix or a feature the next owner would have to change. A floor plan can clear up confusion about room size. If buyers consistently want a larger kitchen, get a realistic sense of the cost before deciding whether to do work or account for the kitchen in your price.

If I cut the price, how much should I cut it?

Ask your agent to show you where the proposed price puts your home among the alternatives, then run the numbers on what you would take home at that price. A round-number reduction is easy to announce. You deserve to know what it would accomplish. See our guide to DC seller closing costs and net proceeds.

If you’re making this call now, bring the feedback and the address of the home buyers keep mentioning. We can pull up both listings and talk through the question I’d ask if it were my house: “If you had my asking price to spend this week, which other home would you tour, and how does mine compare?” Talk with Fed City Team about your sale.

About the author

Marc Dosik

Marc Dosik, Fed City Team at Real Broker LLC

Marc Dosik is the associate broker who leads Fed City Team at Real Broker LLC. Licensed since 1998, he works with sellers across DC, Maryland and Virginia on pricing, preparation and offer terms. Reach Marc at (202) 543-7283 or [email protected].

Check out this article next

Selling an Inherited Condo in Washington, DC: Documents, Fees, and Building Rules

Selling an Inherited Condo in Washington, DC: Documents, Fees, and Building Rules

By Marc Dosik. A practical guide to association documents, condo fees, special assessments, building rules and sale planning for an inherited Washington, DC condo.

Read Article
About the Author
Marc Dosik
Marc is the Associate Broker and primary decision-maker for Fed City Team. He's lived in the Washington DC metro area all his life and has been a licensed broker since 1998. Marc knows and understands the DC area market and specializes in contracts, negotiation tactics, grant programs for home buyers, short sales and foreclosures, and 1031 Exchanges.

If you’re selling in, or relocating to the DC area, contact the Fed City Team today.